Difference with cross cultural cultural Ethnopsychology, and volker Psychology
|
Cross-cultural psychology is a branch of psychology that explores the similarities and differences in thinking and behavior between individuals from different cultures.
Show
Scientists using a cross-cultural approach focus on and compare participants from diverse cultural groups to examine ways in which cognitive styles, perception, emotional expression, personality, and other psychological features relate to cultural contexts. They also compare cultural groups on broad dimensions such as individualism and collectivism—roughly, how much a culture emphasizes its members’ individuality versus their roles in a larger group. Psychologists who are interested in expanding psychology’s focus on diverse cultures have pointed out that the majority of research participants are, to use a popular term, WEIRD: they are from Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, and Democratic societies. Cross-cultural research has made it clear that what psychologists conclude about this slice of the world’s population does not always extend to people with other cultural backgrounds. Contents
What Is Cross-Cultural Psychology?
Psychology’s mission to understand how humans think and behave requires studying humanity as broadly as possible—not just the humans to which researchers tend to be nearest. Psychologists who conduct cross-cultural research investigate the richness of human psychological variation across the world, including points of consistency and divergence between populations with distinct cultural backgrounds, such as those in Western and East Asian countries. Why is cross-cultural psychology important?Created with Sketch. Psychological research that incorporates a more global sample of people provides insights into whether findings and models (such as those about the structure of personality or the nature of mental illness) are universal or not, the extent to which psychological phenomena and characteristics vary across cultures, and the potential reasons for these differences. Cross-cultural research demonstrates that experimental effects, correlations, or other results that are observed in one cultural context—for example, the tendency of Western participants to rate their abilities as better-than-average—do not always appear in the same way, or at all, in others. How is culture defined in psychology?Created with Sketch. While various definitions are used, culture can be understood as the collection of ideas and typical ways of doing things that are shared by members of a society and have been passed down through generations. These can include norms, rules, and values as well as physical creations such as tools. Which groups are compared in cross-cultural psychology?Created with Sketch. Cross-cultural studies allow psychologists to make comparisons and inferences about people from different countries or from broader geographic regions (such as North America or the Western world). But psychologists also compare groups at smaller scales, such as people from culturally distinct subpopulations or areas of the same country, or immigrants and non-immigrants. Is cross-cultural psychology the same as cultural psychology?Created with Sketch. While there is overlap between these approaches, there are also differences. Cross-cultural psychology analyzes characteristics and behavior across different cultural groups, with an interest in variation as well as human universals. Cultural psychology involves comparison as well, but has been described as more focused on psychological processes within a particular culture. In another approach, indigenous psychology, research methods, concepts, and theories are developed within the context of the culture being studied. article continues after advertisement Psychological Differences Across Cultures
The inhabitants of different regions and countries have a great deal in common: They build close social relationships, follow rules established by their communities, and engage in important rituals. But globally, groups also exhibit somewhat different psychological tendencies in domains ranging from the strictness of local rules to how happiness and other emotions are conceived. Of course, within each region, nation, or community, there is plenty of individual variation; people who share a culture never think and act in exactly the same way. Cross-cultural psychology seeks to uncover how populations with shared cultures differ on average from those with other cultural backgrounds—and how those differences tie back to cultural influence. Do emotions differ across cultures?Created with Sketch. While there are shared aspects of emotional experience across cultural groups, culture seems to influence how people describe, evaluate, and act on emotions. For example, while the experience of shame follows perceived wrongdoing across cultures, having shame may be evaluated more positively in some cultures than in others and may be more likely to prompt behavioral responses such as reaching out to others rather than withdrawing. Different emotional concepts (such as “anxiety,” “fear,” and “grief”) may also be thought of as more or less closely related to each other in different cultures. And cultural differences have been observed with regard to how emotions are interpreted and the “display rules” that individuals learn about appropriate emotional expression. Does culture affect how we think about happiness?Created with Sketch. While happiness seems to be one of the most cross-culturally recognizable emotions in terms of individual expression, culture can influence how one thinks about happiness. Research indicates that people in different cultures vary in how much value they place on happiness and how much they focus on their own well-being. Culture may also affect how people believe happiness should be defined and achieved—whether a good life is to be found more in individual self-enhancement or through one’s role as part of a collective, for example. How do cultural differences relate to mental illness?Created with Sketch. Some mental health conditions, in addition to being reported at markedly different rates in different countries, can also be defined and even experienced in different ways. The appearance of depression may depend partly on culture—with mood-related symptoms emphasized in how Americans think of depression, for example, and bodily symptoms potentially more prominent in China. Features of certain cultural groups, such as highly stable social networks, may also serve as protective factors against the risk of mental illness. Increased understanding of cultural idiosyncrasies could lead to gains in mental health treatment. What are individualism and collectivism?Created with Sketch. Individualism and collectivism are two of the contrasting cultural patterns described in cross-cultural psychology. People in relatively collectivist cultures are described as tending to define themselves as parts of a group and to heed the norms and goals of the group. Those in relatively individualistic cultures are thought to emphasize independence and to favor personal attitudes and preferences to a greater degree. Cross-cultural psychologists have pointed to East Asia, Latin America, and Africa as regions where collectivism is relatively prominent and much of Europe, the U.S., and Canada as among those where individualism is more pronounced. But individualism-collectivism is thought of as a continuum, with particular countries, and cultures within those countries, showing a balance of each. What are cultural tightness and looseness?Created with Sketch. Tightness and looseness are contrasting cultural patterns related to how closely people adhere to social rules. Each culture has its own rules and norms about everything from acceptable public behavior to what kinds of intimate relationships are allowed. But in some cultures, or even in particular domains within cultures (such as the workplace), the importance placed on rules and norms and the pressure on people to follow them are greater than in other cultural contexts. Relatively rule-bound cultures have been described as “tight” cultures, while more permissive cultures are called “loose.” As with individualism and collectivism, tightness and looseness are thought of as opposite ends of the same dimension. Is culture relevant to individual personality differences?Created with Sketch. It seems to be. In the West, the Big Five model of personality traits and related models were developed to broadly map out personality differences, and they have been tested successfully in multiple countries. But research suggests that in some cultures, the Big Five traits are not necessarily the best way to describe how people perceive individual differences. Scientists have also found that associations between personality traits and outcomes that appear in some cultures may not be universal. For example, while more extraverted North Americans appear to be happier, on average, extraverts may not have the same advantage elsewhere. Do mating preferences differ across cultures?Created with Sketch. While some mating preferences, such as a desire for kindness and physical attractiveness in a partner, appear in many if not all cultures, preferences also differ in some ways across cultures—like the importance placed on humor or other traits. In the realm of physical attraction, both men’s preferences and women’s preferences seem to depend partly on the cultural context, with research suggesting that men in wealthier societies more strongly favor women of average-to-slender weight, for instance. What are analytic and holistic cognitive styles?Created with Sketch. In cross-cultural psychology, an analytic cognitive style roughly describes a tendency to focus on a salient object, person, or piece of information (as in an image or a story) independently from the context in which it appears. A holistic cognitive style, in contrast, involves a tendency to focus more on the broader context and relationship between objects. Using a variety of tasks—such as one in which a scene with both focal objects and background elements is freely described—psychologists have reported evidence that participants from Western cultures (like the U.S.) tend to show a more analytic cognitive style, while those from East Asian cultures (like Japan) show a more holistic cognitive style. Analytic thinking and holistic thinking have been theorized to stem, respectively, from independent and interdependent cultural tendencies. The WEIRDness of Psychology
The psychological findings that get the most attention are disproportionately derived from a fraction of the world’s population. Some scientists call this relatively well-examined subgroup of human societies WEIRD: that is, Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, and Democratic. As long as people who live in countries that meet these descriptors are the primary subjects of psychological research—and that has long been the case—it will often be difficult for psychologists to determine whether an observation applies to people in general or only to those in certain cultural contexts. Increasing the representation of people from diverse cultures in research is therefore a goal of many psychologists. Which cultures are called WEIRD?Created with Sketch. WEIRD populations are those who are broadly part of the Western world and who live in democratic societies that feature high levels of education, wealth, and industrialization. While there is not a single agreed-upon list of WEIRD cultures—and populations within particular countries can show different levels of these characteristics—commonly cited examples of WEIRD countries include the U.S., Canada, the U.K. and other parts of Western Europe, and Australia. Where did the term WEIRD come from?Created with Sketch. Sampling top psychology journals in the mid-2000s, psychologist Jeffrey Arnett observed that 96 percent of research subjects came from Western, industrialized countries that represented just 12 percent of the world’s population, and that about two-thirds were from the U.S. Subjects seemed to largely be sourced from the countries in which the researchers lived. In 2010, citing this finding and others, Joseph Henrich, Steven Heine, and Ara Norenzayan introduced the term WEIRD to describe this subpopulation. They expanded on the problems with focusing so exclusively on such participants and with assuming that findings from a relatively unrepresentative group generalized to the rest of the world. How much has psychology expanded its focus beyond WEIRD people?Created with Sketch. In numerical terms, it seems, not much. While the problems with global underrepresentation in psychology research have gained more attention in recent years, an updated analysis of top journals in the mid-2010s found that the vast majority of samples were still from Western, industrialized countries, with about 60 percent from the U.S. Why are WEIRD cultures different from other ones?Created with Sketch. In many ways, WEIRD populations seem to be less representative of humans in general than non-WEIRD populations are. Overlapping with other findings from cross-cultural psychology, psychological differences between people from relatively WEIRD countries and those from elsewhere have been noted: WEIRD samples show higher levels of individualism and lower levels of conformity, on average, among other characteristics. One scientist behind the WEIRD concept theorizes that societal changes in the West caused by the Catholic Church, and their subsequent cultural impact, help explain these signature differences. Essential Reads
Why Are Poland and Peru Similar? Seemingly different cultures may be more similar than you think. The reason why? Ecology.  Raising Awareness of Third-Culture Students Where are you from? Raising awareness of "third-culture students" in higher education.
Why Are South Asian Men "Angry"? Exploring the stereotype of the "angry" South Asian male and the possible causes. Using Ayahuasca and Psychedelic Plants to Treat Racial Trauma Psychedelic plant medicines like ayahuasca can foster wellness and healing in people of color coping with the pain of racism. Recent Posts
Race and Ethnicity The Science of Korean Beauty Products and WhitenessPaul Youngbin Kim Ph.D. on December 3, 2022 in Culture, Religion, and Psychology What's the big deal about Jesus's race? What's the big deal about Jesus's race?
Asian-American Adolescent Mental HealthDorothy Chin Ph.D. on November 23, 2022 in A Different Lens Asian-American adolescents are experiencing high levels of anxiety and depression. What's behind the trend and how can parents help? Asian-American adolescents are experiencing high levels of anxiety and depression. What's behind the trend and how can parents help?
Education Learning the Psychology of Xi Jinping to Understand ChinaJonathan Wai Ph.D. on November 14, 2022 in Finding the Next Einstein A new book by political scientist Alfred Chan explores Xi’s childhood, career, and decision-making through a multidisciplinary perspective, shedding light on China. A new book by political scientist Alfred Chan explores Xi’s childhood, career, and decision-making through a multidisciplinary perspective, shedding light on China.
Ethics and Morality Rings of Power and PrivilegeAnjan Chatterjee MD, FAAN on November 14, 2022 in Brain, Behavior, and Beauty Most people harbor negative biases against people with facial differences, such as scars. Popular culture plays a divisive role in promoting these biases and needs to be countered. Most people harbor negative biases against people with facial differences, such as scars. Popular culture plays a divisive role in promoting these biases and needs to be countered.
An NGO Addressing Mental Health Needs in AfricaRobert Schweitzer Ph.D. on October 25, 2022 in Global Events A program addresses the mental health needs of women in Uganda and Zambia. A program addresses the mental health needs of women in Uganda and Zambia.
Around the World, Who Spends Time on Their Looks and Why?Laith Al-Shawaf Ph.D. on October 25, 2022 in Six Impossible Things Before Breakfast Around the world, who spends time on their physical appearance and why? A 93-country study with 93,000 participants reveals the answers. Around the world, who spends time on their physical appearance and why? A 93-country study with 93,000 participants reveals the answers.
Cross-Cultural Psychology America: Living Under Spells of Contempt and IdealizationRavi Chandra M.D., D.F.A.P.A. on October 5, 2022 in The Pacific Heart Contempt and self-idealization are distortions in history and interpersonal life. First Nations are calling for an apology for one example of contempt, the Doctrine of Discovery. Contempt and self-idealization are distortions in history and interpersonal life. First Nations are calling for an apology for one example of contempt, the Doctrine of Discovery.
Adverse Childhood Experiences Justice Capital and Unequal Access to JusticeKendra J Thomas Ph.D. on October 5, 2022 in Positive Growth and Development How psychology can improve conversations around the pursuit of a more just world. How psychology can improve conversations around the pursuit of a more just world.
The Value of Pets in Ukraine During the Russian InvasionStanley Coren PhD., DSc, FRSC on October 4, 2022 in Canine Corner Many Ukrainian families remained in the war zone to take care of their pets, and fewer than 10% who fled Kyiv left their dogs and cats behind. What is the difference between crossCross-cultural psychology analyzes characteristics and behavior across different cultural groups, with an interest in variation as well as human universals. Cultural psychology involves comparison as well, but has been described as more focused on psychological processes within a particular culture.
What is the relationship between cultural psychology and crossCultural psychologists study patterns in behaviors, and how culture, in general, influences those behaviors, while cross-cultural psychologists study the patterns (i.e. similarities and differences) amongst various cultural groups, and how those patterns affect behaviors.
What studies crossThe American Psychological Association describes cross-cultural psychology as being interested in the “similarities and variances in human behavior across different cultures” to identify “the different psychological constructs and explanatory models used by these cultures” (APA Dictionary of Psychology, 2020).
What are the two main types of cultures psychology?Cultural orientation: collectivistic and individualistic
A main distinction to understand when looking at psychology and culture is the difference between individualistic and collectivistic cultures.
|
